Skip to content

Poisoning the Well: When Cybersecurity Startups Sell the Hype, Not the Product

By Lytical Ventures

3 min read
Abstract dark image of a glowing blue ring surrounded by tangled teal and blue light filaments, like a well of light seen from above.

Too many security startups are optimizing for the acquisition press release instead of the product customers will still renew.

Key takeaways

  • Something is broken in cybersecurity venture capital: too many startups are built to be acquired rather than to solve problems.
  • The playbook is predictable: a startup finds a niche, Gartner names a category, platforms race to buy the top player at two to three times the last round, and the press release about strategic alignment doubles as marketing.
  • Israel's cybersecurity pride has sometimes turned into reflexive local buying; one VC discounts the first $3M of Israeli startup revenue to zero, and one acquirer watched $9M of ARR evaporate after a deal.
  • Hype is the poison and execution is the antidote: durable security companies ship products customers renew, not new acronyms or inflated ARR.

Something is broken in cybersecurity venture capital. Too many startups are building to be acquired, not to solve problems.

But before we get into that, a confession: we are East Coast investors. Yes, the kind who used to be mocked for caring about things like "revenues" and "profitability." Now that our shameful secret is out, we hope you will let us explain.

EAST VS. WEST

Historically, West Coast VCs had a reputation for swinging for the fences while East Coasters were seen as the cautious ones counting receipts. In 2021, that made us boring. Then the bubble burst and suddenly we were geniuses. Today? Depends who you ask. Some say growth at all costs, some say… HOLD THE PRESS — This Just In. We are Getting Word Of A Possible AI Bubble Developing Over Silicon Valley. You get the idea. The pendulum never stops swinging.

But let’s be honest, the cool kids have always been and will always be the ones who throw caution to the wind and invest in Clubhouse at a $4 billion valuation.

STILL, SOMETHING FEELS OFF

Now that our coastal shame is out, maybe you will forgive us for saying the quiet part out loud: something feels broken in the security startup market.

Companies are getting acquired on hype alone. Before you go all "wait till they find out the moon is not made of cheese" on us — yes, we know this is not new. But in cybersecurity, it kind of is. The goal is not sustainable revenue; it is building just enough momentum to get swallowed by a platform giant.

Here is how the game works:

  1. A cybersecurity startup finds an underserved niche.
  2. Gartner notices and creates a new category — think SOAR (Security Orchestration, Automation, and Response), CSPM (Cloud Security Posture Management), or UEBA (User and Entity Behavior Analytics).
  3. Platform players notice they are in the lower-left of a new Gartner quadrant. CISOs start asking about their roadmap.
  4. Each platform races to buy a startup for 2–3x the last round, often outbidding the next investor.
  5. The buyer pays a huge ARR multiple and issues a press release about "strategic alignment." Overpaying becomes marketing.
  6. When customers ask about the category, they are told: "We just bought the top player. Integration coming soon."

We will let you decide if it ever actually gets integrated.

Of course, there are exceptions, and to any corp dev folks reading this, your deal was definitely the exception.

POISONING THE WELL: ISRAELI EDITION

Israel’s rise in cybersecurity is a point of national pride — and rightly so. The country’s security services have become a global talent incubator. The only deals pricier than Bay Area startups are Israeli cybersecurity startups. That has been a good thing… mostly.

Somewhere along the way, pride turned into reflex. "Buying local" became a badge of honor, sometimes even when the buyer had no real intention of using the product. Do not believe us?

Two insider anecdotes: A well-known cybersecurity VC told us he discounts the first $3M of Israeli startup revenue to zero. "It is not real," he said — it is just friends and local buyers. A major platform acquired an Israeli company with $9M in ARR. Within a year, most of it had evaporated. Turns out, customers had not been using the product, and post-acquisition, customers did not renew. That acquirer now refuses to buy any more Israeli startups, unless it is forced to, since many of its bake-off decisions now come from Israeli teams it acquired earlier.

We love and admire the Israeli ecosystem. But even the strongest markets can poison their own wells if loyalty replaces merit. If we, the cybersecurity ecosystem, want to protect companies from the bad guys, then we need to reward solving real problems — not just playing the game.

FINAL THOUGHTS

Real security does not come from new acronyms or inflated ARR. It comes from solving hard problems, shipping products that customers actually need, and doing the unsexy things that get customers to renew. Hype is the poison; execution is the antidote.

If you appreciate our highlights and heresies, follow us on Twitter and LinkedIn, we post regularly about real things worthy of your attention.

Questions this article answers

Why does Lytical Ventures say cybersecurity venture capital is broken?
Because acquisitions increasingly reward hype over product. Startups optimize for a Gartner category and a platform buyer rather than sustainable revenue, and platform giants pay large ARR multiples for roadmap cover, then may never integrate what they bought.
What does poisoning the well mean in the Israeli cybersecurity context?
Loyalty replacing merit. When local buyers purchase products they do not intend to use, early revenue stops meaning anything, and acquirers who get burned pull back from the whole ecosystem, which hurts the strong companies too.
What does Lytical Ventures look for instead?
Real revenue and renewals. As East Coast investors who care about revenue and profitability, Lytical backs teams solving hard problems and doing the unsexy work that gets customers to renew.